Selling your Jewelry, watches, and precious metals

Do you have loose or broken jewelry just lying around collecting dust? Well, why not sell it! Here at Dunkin’s Diamonds, we buy your unused jewelry for more than typical jewelry stores. We trade with no hidden fees and complete honesty. Plus, as the leading estate jewelry buyer in Ohio and Southwest Florida, Dunkin's Diamonds has your back and hopes to create a sense of trust that no other diamond retailer can offer.

Why choose Dunkin's Diamonds to sell your goods?

We know it can be difficult to part ways with jewelry that has sentimental value or some other significance to your life. That's why at Dunkin’s Diamonds, we put you first. We guarantee that you are getting the best price for your jewelry. Even though no amount of money can ever overshadow the story behind your jewelry, it definitely feels better to part with it when you know you got the greatest deal. Why else are we a good choice for you?

  • We are fast: After your trade, we provide fast payment for your purchase to ensure that you get your money hastily. No funny business.
  • No obligation appraisals: At Dunkin’s Diamonds, we will NEVER force you into a trade. If you want to get your jewelry appraised, we will simply make you an offer afterward. If you don’t like what you see you are by no means obligated to take the deal. An honest appraisal is meant to assess the value of something, not manipulate you into a deal.
  • Top dollar for your goods: we offer you more than most jewelers for your jewelry.
  • We accept almost everything: From Rolex watches to Emeralds, we buy them. Read below to see what else we buy

What we buy

  • Diamonds
  • Gold
  • Platinum
  • Emeralds
  • Sapphires
  • Rubies
  • Rolex
  • Jewelry: including- Tacori, Tiffany, Carter, Bulgari, Van Cleef, and more.

How does the selling process work?

First, you will need to head on down to one of our locations in Ohio and Florida, where our expert jewelers can meet with. Come with your valid picture I.D. and your jewelry. Immediately we will weigh your items and make you a cash offer right on the spot.

Mail-in service and Virtual appointments.

Don’t want to step out into the real world? We don’t blame you, especially with everything going on. The good thing is you don’t have to! You can schedule an online appointment with us in the comfort of your own home, there we will work with you to find the best method for you to get your items appraised.

Thank you for even considering Dunkin’s Diamonds

When you choose us to take care of your jewelry, just know you are extending the love and passion we harbor for estate jewelry. We appreciate every sale, and our goal is to share that love with you by giving you the best deal. You help us expand our collection and we help you expand your wallet.